This product is perfect for an oil based cleanser. The smell isn't strong at all and melts my makeup right off. It's oil but once you wash it off with water it becomes a milky looking liquid.  

This cleansing balm does a good job removing my makeup, even my waterproof makeup. However, I don't really like the texture of the balm - it feels oily - but it does go away once I wash it all off. 

It's really creamy and effective