I started with Banila co. and changed over to this. I think i prefer it. I would say they both have good cleansing power and remove liquid eyeliner effectively. 

Personally, I prefer this packaging. Also comes with a spatula. Will continue to use this. 

Best makeup remover i have ever used. It melts everything away effortlessly, none irritating not drying. Loved everything about this.

Heimish all clean balm is great and I think it is better than the banila co! 

super gentle, but removes makeup like no other!!  

a really good cheaper dupe for the 'Take the day off' cleanser balm by clinique  

I have used both this product and the Banilla Co. Clean it Zero Oil Balm Cleansers and hands down, I love this product so much! This is supppeerrr gentle but does an amazing job at removing my stubborn water-proof makeup! It also doesn't make my skin feel dry at the end either. Some of the creators of the Banilla Co. Cleanser actually went to Heimish and created this product so this is basically like a perfected version! The packaging is also totally cute and my kind of aesthetic! The only thing I disliked was the smell. I'm not a fan of botanical scents!